Judge Blocks Upcoming Overtime Rule

In a federal ruling in Texas, a judge said the Labor Department's new regulations are inconsistent with what Congress intended.

November 23, 2016

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Texas federal District Judge Amos Mazzant has preliminarily blocked the U.S. Labor Department’s new overtime rule, which was set to go into effect on December 1. In a ruling yesterday, Mazzant blocked the implementation or enforcement of the salary-related changes in the federal Fair Labor Standards Act's "white collar" exemptions. He issued his Tuesday afternoon decision in response to an emergency motion by 21 states that had filed suit seeking to invalidate the Labor Department's actions.

Judge Mazzant said that the Labor Department's new regulations are inconsistent with what Congress intended for these exemptions. He also concluded that, while Congress gave the Labor Department the power to define these exemptions, the agency had exceeded that authority.

A similar Texas lawsuit brought by a number of business groups and employer advocates has been consolidated with the states' case. Judge Mazzant ruled in the states' lawsuit only, but he extended his order nationwide and did not say that the injunction was limited to the states alone.

While for the moment the Labor Department's new regulations are not scheduled to go into effect as previously ruled, it is important to understand that this is a temporary injunction and that the Labor Department is likely to appeal in every way it can.

Oral arguments for summary judgment in the overtime case are scheduled for Monday, November 28. It is unclear which side of the issue will prevail, so convenience retailers should still be prepared for a December 1 enforcement date.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement