Maverik, Sheetz, Wawa and More Recognized for Loyalty Programs

Many c-stores made Newsweek’s annual list of America’s Best Loyalty Programs.

February 23, 2024

Newsweek released its fourth annual list of America’s Best Loyalty Programs 2024, and many convenience retailers made the list. The global loyalty management ecosystem will be worth $24 billion by the end of 2029, Newsweek said, citing data from data analysis firm Statista.

To create the list, Newsweek partnered with Statista to rank more than 300 loyalty programs across 40 categories.

The results were compiled based on the results of an independent survey of more than 4,000 U.S. customers who are members of loyalty program, Newsweek said. The final assessment and rankings were based on six criteria: ease and enjoyment; benefit; overall satisfaction; customer support; trust; and recommendation.

Here are the convenience stores and their rewards programs that made the list.

Convenience Store subcategory:

  • QT Rewards from QuikTrip, 8.94
  • My Sheetz Rewardz from Sheetz, 8.61
  • Wawa Rewards from Wawa, 8.35
  • SmartPay Rewards from Cumberland Farms, 8.06
  • Refreshing Rewards from bp’s Thorntons,7.97
  • Casey’s Rewards from Casey’s General Stores, 7.95
  • ROFO Rewards from Royal Farms, 7.86
  • Huck’s Bucks from Martin & Bayley Inc./Huck’s, 7.8
  • Speedy Rewards from Speedway, 7.75
  • 7REWARDS from 7-Eleven, 7.73
  • ampm App from bp’s ampm, 7.57
  • Enjoy rewards from Enmarket, 7.39
  • Kwik Rewards from Kwik Trip, 7.22
  • &Rewards from Kum & Go, 7.21
  • Chevron Texaco Rewards from Chevron, 6.96

Gas Station subcategory:

  • Adventure Club from Maverik, 9.07
  • Casey’s Rewards from Casey’s General Stores, 8.99
  • Kwik Rewards from Kwik Trip, 8.76
  • Sunoco Go Rewards from Sunoco, 8.72
  • MYReward$ from MAPCO, 8.6
  • Chevron Texaco Rewards from Chevron, 8.18
  • Speedy Rewards from Speedway, 7.8
  • RaceTrac Rewards from RaceTrac, 7.75
  • Fuel Rewards from Shell, 7.7
  • My Sheetz Rewardz from Sheetz, 7.63
  • KickBack Rewards from 76, 7.21
  • Wawa Rewards from Wawa, 7.17
  • GetGo Fleet from GetGo, 7.05
  • BPme Rewards from bp, 6.82
In addition, Upside, the rewards app that includes brands such as Speedway, Valero, Marathon, Racetrac, bp and Circle K, was included in the general reward programs category with a score of 8.08.